9 Comments
User's avatar
Noah Chon Lee's avatar

This should be in a three body problem episode

Charles Pye's avatar

So, sometimes I think this way. Like, if we meet aliens, they should be much better than us at math, right?

but lately I've been into chess. And there's these chess moves that were played, like, 400 years ago, and totally figured out. Any modern grandmaster would never play them. But for a normal person, they're still a reasonable chess move. What if the aliens are still playing these sort of "obsolete, but non-obvious" moves?

Jehan Azad's avatar

This is a good point. It also reminds me of how computer programs used to be hyper-optimized for disk space because there was so little of it available. Nowadays, we don't care if things get bloated because it's no longer a bottleneck. So we might seem surprisingly bad at memory optimization to another civilization.

All that said, being able to factor a 10-digit number is a sufficient, but not necessary, condition to prove superhumanness.

Handle's avatar

The problem is that often one can't remember much of one's interactions with the entities or use the internet ably when seeing them, so if they tell one the factors, one still won't be able to verify them. Tragic.

Jehan Azad's avatar

This is the tough part, yeah.

Adam Mastroianni's avatar

I understand that if I’m dealing with normal intelligence, my prime totem will be greeted with a blank stare, an excuse, failure, etc. And I understand that if I’m dealing with true omniscience, my prime totem will be greeted by the right answer immediately. But what if I’m dealing with something in between? Maybe something much much smarter than me, but not something that knows everything. What will it look like then?

Jehan Azad's avatar

Good question! Hopefully, asking a supernatural entity to factor a 10-digit number will be like asking a normal person to factor 77, where many of us could quickly find the factors 7 and 11.

The entity would need to be smarter than any human, but not omniscient, to factor a 10-digit balanced semiprime. Your smartphone can do this in a fraction of a second.

That said, maybe 10 digits is too many for some of these beings. I've updated PrimeTotem.com to have 5, 7, 10 and 16 digit options, so you can decide your own difficulty level.

Adam Mastroianni's avatar

Thanks! Also wondering which would be more impressive:

1) the entity can factor the 10-digit number immediately

2) the entity has unobtrusive fMRI technology and can read your memorized answer off your neural activity

Jehan Azad's avatar

#2 would be way more impressive, I think! The problem is that the entity could just be part of your own mind, and so could access your memory without any fancy fMRI tech.